Pages

Wednesday, September 22, 2010

Low carb diets like Atkins 'better for blood pressure'

There is a healthier way to go about tackling obesity. In this hard news story the author presents the reader with a more natural alternative to weight loss. A benefit of a low-carb diet is its considerable effect on lowering blood pressure. The key standpoint the author is presenting is to use diet instead of medication. In using diet the individual will experience fewer costs and negative side effects. This proposal is supported by reliable scientific sources including the Archives of Internal Medicine, the Veterans Affairs Medical Centre and Duke University Medical Centre and the British Heart Foundation.

The author leads the reader into the article by using a statement confirmed by US doctors. On a low-carb diet twice as many people have lower blood pressure than people using orlistat (diet drugs). The author tries not to be biased in confirming that both approaches to dieting have achieved equal weight loss. Overweight people are often advised to loose weight to lower their blood pressure this gives the reader an underlying direction towards using a low-carb diet.

The article uses common terms that are easy to understand and a number of sub-headings are used to guide the reader. Each of the two sections ‘medication’ and ‘counselling’ are both supported by research statistics. The author enhanced this with quotes by reputable sources.

It is most important for the author to make it very clear that this diet can be a more effective and well-rounded alternative to weight loss. A further aspect influencing the weight loss is counselling. Only minimal information is provided on the effects counselling the rest of the paragraph is dedicated to describing diet drugs. This may suggest that the author is trying to balance out the argument, giving the reader further information.

In conclusion a general health statement is made by the well-recognised source the British Health Foundation. The author gives the reader the choice suggesting that they themselves need to find something to suite their own needs.

Colon cancer cases ‘may rise 50%’

In this hard news story, the author jumps right in establishing that there will be a 50% increase in the number of new colon cancer cases in the UK, over the next 30 years. This comes across as shock value. In backing the findings using research from the European Journal of Cancer, the reader feels that this is valid data. Nonetheless, once the reader realises that the author is looking at predictions towards the next 30 years, these could be impacted by other external factors.


A number of studies have been made in seven different countries to predict the rates of colon cancer. However, the author says that these studies ‘might’ give the reader space for doubt.The story follows on with the main risk factors explaining why being overweight and colon cancer go hand in hand.


In order to convey how applied computer models can predict the impact of external factors on weight loss, the author uses the research of Dr Andrew Renehan, from the University of Manchester, as well as other author’s research. If the obesity and activity levels stay the same these predictions can come true. Nonetheless, many people know that many things can change and impact such predictions during such a long period of time.


The other paragraph goes on to explain when these values will rise or drop, without ever suggesting any way of prevention. The reader also needs to keep in mind that these are all predictions rather than facts.It seems as if the author is not quiet sure what argument he or she is trying to bring across. The quote by Dr Renehan does not come across as being the best way of explaining the current and future impacts of external influences. Straight after another quote by Professor Jan-Willem Coebergh is used to elaborate on what the prior quote was supposed to bring across in a more simple way. A second study brings forth that it is not only obese individuals that carry excess weight around the waist, but also individuals with BMI below 28.


Nevertheless, the author has still not explained what can be done to prevent colon cancer or treat it. In the second last paragraph not having explained colon cancer at all the author now goes on to explaining bowl cancer. This article contains a vast number of quotes and references to research but lacks flow, clarity and meaning.

Saturday, August 21, 2010

Addiction drugs may boost weight loss


Throughout day-to-day life, obesity has a significant impact especially in the US and more and more in the UK. Obesity is affecting individuals of all ages and is causing strain on health care. The combination of Naltrexone and Buropion are suggested to facilitate the process of weight loss.


This hard-news story provides the reader with hard facts. The author builds on the current and past research, creating a reliable base from which the reader can gain an understanding. The link to the Lancet report is provided at the bottom of the page enabling further investigation. However, there is no link to the UK study of which greater detail is provided in the article. The details give the reader the feeling of having a thorough review of the research and reducing the need to read around the subject. As a rule, this holds true as the BBC is a credible website. Nevertheless, when reading less credible websites it is important for the reader be more cautious of trusting information given.


Furthermore, by using quotes provided by Professor Nick Finer, an obesity expert from University College London (UCL), the author increases the article’s credibility. Also by explaining the placebo effect, it allows individuals with non-science backgrounds to follow the effects of the study. In giving the reader access to the results stated in the findings, (which included specific data and side effects), the author has made it easy to follow through what was been accomplished up to this point, thus engaging the reader’s trust.


But she does not stop there. To increase the reader’s line of thought a further idea of drug regulation and health risk is brought forth. Again backing such ideas using expert Professor Frank Greenway’s quotes. Individuals are made aware that the drug (which affects appetite and reward centres in the brain) might be a quick fix to weight loss.


The article concludes with a quote that could make readers a little sceptic of the research. They say they work in the best interest of the patient, but do they? When thinking of the money that is made from such drugs, there seem to be other intentions.

Thursday, August 19, 2010

Obesity drug fears investigated


Women are especially affected by current society trends that skinny/thin is beautiful. To achieve this may cause them to use ‘Alli’; a quick fix to solve their problems. The author of the article wants to reveal what people thought of as a short cut to their weight problems comes at a cost: Peoples’ health. The research used to back the negative claims is provided by both the US and UK national health bodies. This increases the readers’ sense of trust of the validity of the findings.

The news story has the same structure as a journal article, providing the most recent claims of anti-obesity drugs causing liver damage. The author writes in a clear and no scientific language making it easy for the reader to follow and become intellectually engaged. The reader is given an insight into recent reports, including the number of people affected, who the drug is targeted at and how it works in the body. Following on with the impact and reports of liver damage in the last 10 years.

The whole article leans more towards the negative impact. Simultaneously laying out the positive effect (50% more weight loss than dieting alone). This does give the reader the freedom to make up their own mind, however, consistent references to serious side effects diminishes the impact of the positive aspects of the drug. The author shows concern in providing the reader with a list of symptoms in case they still want to use the product they should be aware of.

Subsequently moving to the actions that are being undertaken including product review. Concluding with two controversial statements by the pharmaceutical company suggesting that Alli only specifically affects the gastro-intestinal track and that there is no obvious biological mechanism that would damage the liver. These of course this leaves the reader to think twice next in using a quick fix.

Thursday, August 5, 2010


This blog has risen from the idea that online it is possible to get all sorts of information giving us tips on our health. What works and what doesn’t? But do we really know if it is possible to trust these sources? The goal of this blog is to discuss the evidence that lies beneath its claims.